For a musical called Burlesque, this one has a frustrating habit of cutting the cabaret short. Just as I was settling into a club number, it seemed to be over and we were back with the story. The odd thing was that I liked the story too, especially Ali and Jack’s romance. I enjoyed both sides of the evening, sometimes enormously, but they rarely felt like parts of the same show.
I hadn’t seen the film, and knew little beyond Welcome to Burlesque, so the production’s delayed arrival in Woking made me curious. The theatre was packed, the six piece band sounded terrific and the audience was ready to have a good time. Ali arrives in New York searching for her mother, finds her way into Tess’s club and falls for Jack while the venue’s future comes under threat. There is plenty to work with, if Steven Antin’s book can decide where to put its attention.

Macy Dermody Blythe was performing as the understudy for Ali, which was an exciting prospect rather than a disappointment. I’ve always championed understudies, alternates and standbys: you never know when you might catch somebody at the beginning of an extraordinary career. Blythe made me wonder if I’d just witnessed the arrival of a future icon of musical theatre. She embodied Ali’s eagerness to find her place, and her vocals were exceptional. An a cappella passage let us hear exactly what she could do, while the love duet with Tyler Davis showed another side of her, warmer and more intimate. Her performance needed no qualification for being an understudy. The role belonged to her that night.
Davis makes Jack an endearingly ridiculous romantic. His attempts to impress Ali become increasingly elaborate, culminating in precious little clothing and some strategically placed props working overtime to preserve his modesty. He gets a terrific laugh without turning Jack into a complete fool. The chemistry with Blythe is lovely, and their duet was one of those moments when I thought I might be watching a five star musical. Their relationship moves quickly, but I believed in it.

I was considerably less convinced by Faye Brookes as Tess. She can sing and dance, but that isn’t the same as owning the stage. Cher made Tess iconic on screen, and I wasn’t looking for an imitation; I wanted a woman who made you believe the club was hers the moment she appeared. Brookes rarely had that authority. At times she almost blended into the ensemble, and Diane Warren’s You Haven’t Seen the Last of Me lacked the defiance I wanted, despite the strength of her voice. She also felt young for Tess, both in appearance and in the maturity she brought to the role. I never quite believed in the years of experience this woman was supposed to carry.
The book makes it harder still. Tess has surprisingly little to do in Act Two, just when her relationship with Ali ought to become the main event. I’d have preferred the mother and daughter revelation as the Act One cliffhanger, leaving the second half to explore how two women who barely know each other might become family. Instead, the reconciliation arrives too easily. It’s difficult to feel the impact of a relationship the musical has barely let us see.

Ryan Carter, whom I first saw as Jagwire in Bat Out of Hell, has the command I missed elsewhere. His Sean is wonderfully sassy, his vocals are outstanding and the Ms Loretta material is a gift to his comic instincts. Emma Lloyd’s Queenie and Vanessa Ela Young’s Nikki also catch the eye whenever they appear. Lloyd’s soprano was particularly impressive, but neither character is given enough time to become much more than a memorable club personality. Davide Fienauri faces a similar problem as Vince. The actor has presence; the supposed villain rarely seems threatening enough to justify the fuss around him.
I enjoyed Robin Antin and Aaron Renfree’s choreography. The routines were confidently performed and filled the stage, which made their brevity all the more frustrating. Some club acts barely seemed to last a minute. Welcome to Burlesque was a highlight, but I wanted the musical to trust its own premise and let these performances become a proper show within the show. The principal cast frequently joined the larger formations, and a fuller ensemble might have given the numbers more variety and scale. What was there worked. I wanted considerably more of it.

Sara Perks’ set had its moments. Jack’s apartment and the club were recognisable spaces, and the New York subway setting told us where we were, but I never felt transported into the city or its nightlife. During the preset, performers chatted as they took their places at dressing room mirrors. I understood the backstage idea, though I’d hoped for a bigger entrance. Marco Marco’s costumes were uneven, with the twin performers’ matching pink wigs looking as if they’d come from Poundland. Certain choices strayed towards pantomime rather than glamour. Joshie Harriette’s lighting could be effective, then suddenly distractingly bright. There were echoes of Chicago and Moulin Rouge! in the styling, but where the latter had made me feel completely inside its world, this often resembled a grander show pared back for touring.
Act Two came out with more energy, and the applause was generous. The performance began at 7.30pm and finished at about 10.15pm, yet I still wanted more time with the club acts and with Ali and Tess. That is the problem in miniature. Burlesque has performers who can command a room and a romance I was happy to follow. But until the cabaret and the drama stop taking turns, the show will keep cutting short the very things that make it worth watching.