REVIEW

Annie

THE HAWTH, CRAWLEY · TOURING UNTIL MARCH 2027 · 2 HOURS 20 MINS (INCL. INTERVAL) · REVIEWED BY PETER BARNETT
88%
OVERALL RATING
B+
GRADE
This is an Annie that isn’t afraid to get its hands dirty, and it’s all the better for it.
REVIEWED BY PETER BARNETT · 21 OCTOBER 2026

I’ve seen Annie in several guises over the years, from the rather dark and drab 2012 Broadway revival to an older UK tour, complete with those dreadful, scruffy ginger wigs. Neither quite captured what I love about the musical. Nikolai Foster’s production, however, has always been a favourite. Having previously seen it with Miranda Hart and Craig Revel Horwood as Miss Hannigan, returning to The Hawth in Crawley reminded me why this particular staging still works so well.

Colin Richmond’s set has always been one of my favourite things about this production. Its oversized jigsaw pieces, illustrated New York streets and battered furniture have an almost RSC Matilda the Musical quality. The orphanage, with its worn metal bedsteads and mismatched furnishings, looks suitably neglected. Even before the show begins, the children are already on stage, going about life in their grubby surroundings. It’s a lovely touch that immediately establishes their world. Ben Cracknell’s colourful lighting brings the scenery to life, while the set moves effectively between locations without losing its character. For a touring production, it’s impressive.

The opening barely gives the audience a moment to settle before the musical starts delivering one familiar number after another. Maybe, It’s the Hard Knock Life and Tomorrow arrive with terrific momentum, establishing a brisk pace that rarely lets up. At approximately two hours and twenty minutes, including the interval, the running time feels just right.

The real stars, however, are the children. Victoria Alsina is a wonderful Annie, with strong vocals and a natural stage presence. She’s spirited and determined, yet there’s enough vulnerability in her performance to make Annie’s longing for her parents convincing.

The Chrysler team is quite simply terrific. Their enthusiasm and sheer commitment are remarkable, particularly during It’s the Hard Knock Life, where Nick Winston’s choreography gives them plenty of opportunity to show what they can do. They’re wonderfully unruly, gloriously grubby and completely believable as children who’ve learnt to fend for themselves. There’s a rawness to their performances that I particularly admire, matched by impressive vocals and infectious energy. Ten out of ten for the children, without hesitation.

A particular delight is Jemima Lown as Molly. Making her professional stage debut, she’s small but mighty, with an expressive accent, impressive vocals and a confidence that makes her impossible to overlook. Even among such a talented young company, she repeatedly catches your attention. What a debut.

I’ve always enjoyed Alex Bourne as Oliver Warbucks, particularly because he can really sing. Initially rather reserved, his Warbucks gradually becomes warmer, more playful and completely devoted to the little girl who unexpectedly enters his life. Bourne charts that change beautifully. His scenes with Alsina feel genuinely affectionate, especially their delightful dance together and I Don’t Need Anything But You. It’s the sort of relationship that could easily become overly sentimental, but here it feels entirely believable.

Tanisha-Mae Brown is equally appealing as Grace Farrell, with a gorgeous soprano that reminds me of Audra McDonald’s interpretation of the character in Disney’s 1999 television adaptation. There’s a similar sweetness and elegance to her singing, and she shares an easy affection with Annie and Warbucks. I Think I’m Gonna Like It Here is another musical highlight.

Where the production doesn’t quite reach the heights of its younger cast is with its villains. Claire Sweeney brings plenty of experience to Miss Hannigan, delivering a capable performance with some enjoyable comic touches. Having previously seen Miranda Hart and Craig Revel Horwood tackle the role, I’ve always appreciated the distinctive personalities they brought to it. Sweeney has the singing and dancing ability, but I would have loved to see her push the character’s wickedness and outrageous humour a little further. There’s a particularly amusing moment when she plants a kiss on Warbucks’ bald head, although I found myself waiting for more moments like it. Miss Hannigan is such a wonderfully larger-than-life character, and while Sweeney is certainly enjoyable, I felt there was room for a more individual interpretation.

Christian Cooper and Amber Kennedy make an entertaining pairing as Rooster and Lily, bringing a playful energy to their scheming. Their scenes together are enjoyable, although I would have welcomed a little more mischief and menace from the pair. There’s something delicious about the villains in Annie, particularly when they’re wicked enough to make you want to boo them at the curtain call. I didn’t quite get that here, but there’s still plenty to enjoy in their performances.

The supporting company offers plenty of smaller pleasures. Sophie Elmes, whom I remember from last year’s Dorking pantomime, makes a welcome appearance as Star to Be, while Yujin Park catches the eye with his neat little tap dance, appearance as the Apple Seller and his moment with Wacky the dummy. Harrison Burley enjoys a brief appearance as Bundles, while Elliot David Parkes provides some excellent vocals as Bert Healy at the beginning of Act Two. Carl Sanderson also makes an impression as Franklin Roosevelt.

The eight-piece orchestra, under Nick Tudor’s musical direction, sounds excellent, with the trumpet particularly enjoyable during N.Y.C.. Winston’s choreography remains lively throughout, and then there’s Sandy, played at this performance by the wonderfully trained Dizzy. Whenever the dog appears, it’s difficult to watch anyone else. They say never work with children or animals, but frankly, I’d happily make an exception for this lot.

For all my reservations about the villains, Foster’s Annie remains a production I have enormous affection for. The children are exceptional, Bourne gives the story genuine warmth, and Richmond’s distinctive staging continues to impress. Some productions of Annie are content to be sweet. Foster’s production knows that a little grit goes a long way, and the optimism feels all the more convincing for it.

There’s something particularly satisfying about returning to a production you’ve enjoyed before and finding that it still has the same appeal. Foster’s staging has retained its character over the years, and with such a talented young company bringing it to life, I suspect this won’t be my last visit to the orphanage.

THE VERDICT
88%
OVERALL RATING
STAR RATING
B+
GRADE

Related coverage